Ageless Indie Rockers The Walkmen Dazzle Sold-Out Crowd at Bimbo’s

Photo Credit: Marisa Plaice

Has any band enjoyed a second (and third) act quite like the Walkmen?

The New York quintet burst upon the scene with two perfect albums—their 2002 debut, “Everyone Who Pretended to Like Me Is Gone,” and their explosive 2004 follow up, “Bows + Arrows.” The first album was a twisted vaudevillian update for modern times and their sophomore release was a scathing rejoinder of urban ennui—you could practically feel the stale beer and cigarette smell on the songs.

But by 2007, the band had largely been overshadowed by their New York City peers, with indie darlings like Grizzly Bear and brooding dad rockers The National stealing the headlines. That was mostly the result of their uninspired 2006 album “A Hundred Miles Off,” and their ill-fated cover of Harry Nilson’s album, “The Pussy Cats.”

Seemingly destined to join the endless list of once-promising bands consigned to anonymity, the Walkmen followed up with 2008’s “You and Me,” a tour-de-force that recounted all of “Bows + Arrows” best moments. It was rapturously received, and they then released two other stellar and inventive albums, “Lisbon” and “Heaven,” before going on a hiatus in 2013 (although they have always disputed that term.)

That unexpected comeback alone would have been a great story, but the Walkmen reemerged last year after a decade-long break to stage their “Revenge Tour,” a string of shows that included an array of sold-out dates and prominent festival appearances. The band sounded as sharp as ever in those performances, and their fans had clearly not forgotten them.

While the band has been less active in 2024, they’ve performed at a smattering of music festivals and they scheduled two West Coast shows at Bimbo’s, the venerable North Beach club in San Francisco. On Thursday, July 11, the band performed the first of those two gigs, and hooboy, they did not disappoint.

The Walkmen have always projected a sense of equitable creative collaboration—each member of the group has embarked on various other cprojects—but in a live setting, it’s hard not to be overwhelmed by the sheer presence of lead singer Hamilton Leithauser. 

He might have a name that recalls feudal aristocrats and an appearance that wouldn’t look out of place in Yale’s Skull and Bones Club, but Leithauser is a caterwauling, feral beast onstage. There is no other indie rock singer who reaches the heights of his vociferous wailing, and his facial gesticulations and general intensity in a live setting are just ridiculously infectious—if you don’t feel compelled to scream alongside him, then you damn well might not have a pulse.

The band opened the show with the relatively tranquil “On the Water,” before entering into a devastating back-to-back of “Juveniles” and “In the New Year.” With its call and response of “You’re one of us/Or one of them,” “Juveniles” has earned its spot as a beloved live favorite, and the manic “In the New Year,” with its whirling organ play, is simply one of the best Walkmen songs ever recorded.

The Walkmen flit seamlessly between soft and loud moments (although Leithauser’s vocal theatrics never tend to abate), so quieter tunes like “138th Street” seem to resonate just as profoundly as their more transgressive sounds, such as “Thinking of a Dream I Had.”

Leithauser has always been an able showman, unafraid to charm audiences with his trademark dry humor, and Walkmen shows are typically laden with references to the band’s history. At the show on Thursday, Leithauser referenced the band’s prior stop at Bottom of the Hill—the legendary punk bar in Potrero Hill—and noted that the group’s only previous time playing at Bimbo’s was a “disaster.” He also mentioned that guitarist Paul Maroon’s father, Fred, was a decorated photographer who previously captured stirring pictures of Bimbo’s, some 60 years ago. 

It all felt very homegrown and familial, which makes sense, considering the band all met as high school students in Washington, D.C. And all those years have done nothing to diminish their live show—Maroon is a criminally underrated (and understated) guitarist, and it’s time to concede that the diminutive Matt Barrick is the best indie rock drummer in the world.

In fact, Barrick’s rapid-fire opening salvo is the definitive moment of the band’s definitive song, “The Rat.” Widely regarded as one of the best songs of the century, “The Rat” has long been THE must-see moment of a Walkmen show, and after closing with that number for years, the band steadily moved it up on its setlist. On Thursday, “The Rat” came near the end of their opening act, and unsurprisingly, blew the doors off Bimbo’s. The entire crowd engaged in a near hysteric rendition of the song, faithfully belting out each word at the top of their lungs. 

After closing out their set with the anthemic “Heaven,” (punctuated by its triumphant lines, “Remember, remember/All we fight for!”), the band returned with an encore of “Thinking of a Dream I Had,” and two of their oldest songs, “That’s the Punch Line,” and “We’ve Been Had.” Actually, “We’ve Been Had,” was the first Walkmen song ever recorded, and Leithauser acknowledged—as he has in the past—the significance of this tune, crediting the track with convincing him that his band had legitimate potential.

More than two decades after recording that song in a snowy New York City evening, Leithauser’s initial impressions clearly still ring true. Then as now, the Walkmen are a dynamic, thrilling and endlessly satisfying outfit. Whatever act comes next, it will be worth seeing.

Setlist:

On the Water 

Juveniles 

In the New Year 

Postcards from Tiny Islands 

Angela Surf City 

Dónde Está la Playa 

Woe Is Me 

I Lost You 

138th Street 

What's in It for Me 

Wake Up 

The Rat 

All Hands and the Cook 

Red Moon 

Canadian Girl 

Heaven

**ENCORE**

Thinking of a Dream I Had 

That's the Punch Line

We’ve Been Had